It’s Time for a Full Reset on How I Use Social Media – Ryan Schultz

adem ay Tk9m HP4rgQ unsplash
Picture by Adem AY on Unsplash

Early this morning, I deleted my Reddit account.

As lots of you already know, I deleted my Fb and Instagram accounts in 2018, adopted by shifting away from Fb-now-Meta’s digital actuality {hardware} utterly (I now have a Valve Index at dwelling and an HTC Vive Professional 2 headset at work, each utilizing SteamVR).

And final April, when Elon Musk first floated the thought of shopping for Twitter, I started to reassess my use of that social media platform, too. I arrange my first account on the federated, free-and-open-source (FOSS) microblogging platform Mastodon. So, by the point Elon strode into Twitter headquarters as its new CEO within the fall, I pulled the plug on Twitter as effectively. (Based mostly on some good recommendation I received from infosec of us on Mastodon, I merely deleted all my tweets and chats, then left my account empty, with out truly deleting it. Sometimes, they seem to reload all my deleted tweets from a backup, however I simply run TweetDelete once more to batch delete the whole lot.)

As for YouTube, I solely observe chosen channels through the wonderful Feedbin app, which I had initially written about right here (word that since that was written final October, I made a decision to unfollow all people on Twitter utterly; I solely use Feedbin for newsletters and YouTube channels now). The largest benefit to this setup (and effectively definitely worth the subscription price) is that I’m now not a slave to YouTube’s suggestion algorithm and its incessant, irritating inserted promoting!

Clubhouse lived and died and was deleted from my iPhone over the course of a yr (but it surely was enjoyable whereas it lasted, and a much-needed outlet through the pandemic lockdown).

Which implies, that as of Valentine’s Day 2023, the one corporate-run social media I nonetheless used each day was Reddit. So, why did I lastly eliminate that?

It’s a little bit of a narrative. However basically, one thing occurred this morning that was my wake-up name that I used to be spending far an excessive amount of time on Reddit.

Though I had been conscious of Reddit for a few years, I solely bothered to arrange an account in 2018. At first, I barely used the service, however I did discover that, as I moved away from Fb and Twitter, I used to be spending increasingly time on Reddit.

Initially, I had subscribed to all of the digital actuality and metaverse-related subreddits (what Reddit calls communities). For a short while final yr, I used to be glued to the every day submit on the r/worldnews subreddit in regards to the Russia-Ukraine warfare. And, in fact, Reddit was a spot the place I adopted the most recent information in regards to the ongoing coronavirus pandemic.

Over time, I discovered that I used to be spending much less time on these communities, and extra time on what I name the snark subreddits—these communities which have spring up round a public determine (often a star or an “influencer”), filled with sarcastic and often-hilariously-on-point criticism of their posts on Instagram and different social media websites, in addition to newsmedia protection about them.

A kind of snark subs was known as Hollis Uncensored, and it targeted on the once-married (and now divorced) influencer couple of Dave and Rachel Hollis. Rachel had lucked into changing into an Instagram influencer and convention speaker, and had a well-liked guide printed, titled Woman, Wash Your Face. Dave, who was a profitable government at Disney, determined to depart company life and be a part of the influencer/speaker/author market with Rachel. They labored collectively (together with advising married {couples} on their relationships) proper up till the shock announcement that they had been separating, which in fact received some individuals fairly upset that they had been advertising and marketing themselves as marriage “consultants”.

After the cut up, it wasn’t lengthy earlier than Dave Hollis connected with Heidi Lane Powell, a health influencer who was divorced from Chris Powell (that couple hosted the truth TV present Excessive Weight Loss for a number of years). In a lot the identical method as Dave had latched onto his (ex-)spouse Rachel’s enterprise as an influencer/speaker, so he turned part of Heidi’s work and private life as her enterprise companion and her boyfriend. Seeing a sample right here? So did we, and we gloried in snarking about it!

Effectively, after breaking apart and getting again collectively once more a number of instances, not too long ago Dave and Heidi introduced that they had been separating as a pair (once more). Throughout all this, Dave needed to abruptly cancel a males’s convention we was making an attempt to promote, when he went for therapy at an addictions centre in California—one thing which Heidi by accident let slip throughout a snapshot of a Zoom assembly posted to her social media, the place a very sharp-eyed snarker did a reverse picture search and matched the furnishings and decorations within the room Dave was talking from, with the therapy facility! There have been additionally a number of frankly embarrassing makes an attempt by David, coaxed on by Heidi, to take part in issues like a triathlon (which he bailed out of) and a bodybuilding competitors (the place he got here in final for his age vary).

Evidently, all this supplied ample alternative for the snarkers within the r/hollisuncensored subreddit! Each night, earlier than going to mattress, I’d lie on my couch with my iPad, catching up on Hollis Uncensored and my different favorite snark subreddits. It was like I used to be sitting on the imply ladies’ desk in highschool, gossiping and guffawing about what so-and-so did to such-and-such!

Nonetheless, over time, I observed a disturbing sample in my Reddit behaviour. Usually, I’d shuttle between varied subreddits (together with my present favorite, the cryptosnark neighborhood r/Buttcoin), on the lookout for new gadgets to touch upon. I’d typically keep up previous my common bedtime, restlessly checking for the most recent snark, rechecking to see whether or not my feedback had been upvoted. I used to be changing into addicted.

This morning, whereas brewing a pot of espresso and on the brink of head off to work, I signed into Hollis Uncensored, to learn the surprising information that Dave Hollis had all of a sudden and unexpectedly handed away. Selection broke the story final night time:

Dave Hollis
Dave Hollis’ demise was a wake-up name that I used to be losing totally an excessive amount of time snarking on Reddit

Dave was solely 47 years outdated, and he left behind his ex-wife Rachel and their 4 youngsters (the youngest of whom is barely 5), plus his ex-girlfriend Heidi and her 4 youngsters (from two earlier relationships). It seems that Dave had had a coronary heart situation, and he had truly been hospitalized not too long ago for it whereas attending some form of influencers’ Mastermind summit in California (an occasion that appeared to carry collectively all of the toxic-positivity grifters).

There was a lot anguish expressed right this moment over at r/hollisuncensored, and never a bit of soul-searching. Most individuals are nonetheless processing, and nonetheless in shock. All of the sudden, all that snark about Dave’s, Rachel’s, and Heidi’s antics doesn’t appear that humorous anymore. Some have prompt that the present remark threads about Dave be deleted, even the entire subreddit be shut down, whereas others have pushed again on that concept. One much-upvoted remark within the aftermath of this surprising information reads as follows:

None of us wished this, it was about holding [those] individuals, who train on well-being and well being whereas publicly doing dangerous issues, to account. It’s very unhappy. And [it] goes to point out why we should always take habit and psychological well being critically, from consultants, not this self-help grift. Dave was a sufferer of self-help tradition as a lot as a perpetrator of it. It’s very, very unhappy. I hope these round him who’re additionally struggling from habit and different psychological well being points take this as a wake-up name that they should search skilled, evidenced primarily based assist, to decide to it privately, [and] to not train on it [un]til a very long time after their very own therapeutic. Habit and anguish will not be one thing you possibly can deal with by altering your mindset or shifting your physique and journaling. This fixed whirling round of epiphanies and anguish makes you sicker and additional away from being okay. Don’t observe self helpers, course creators promoting no product, attend[ing] these conferences, masterminds and many others.

Might his household have consolation.

For me, this was my clear signal from the universe that I used to be spending far, far an excessive amount of time on Reddit, and I simply determined to delete my Reddit account this morning, chilly turkey. (My earlier posts and feedback will stay up, however with out my username connected to them. As I did earlier than I arrange a Reddit account, I may nonetheless go in and think about the communities I was a member of, however I can now not remark or submit except I arrange a brand new account, which I’ve zero intention of doing.)

So, what have I discovered from the previous few years, and from right this moment?

I’ve discovered that I’ve a lamentable tendency to change into hooked on social media, notably in these apps like Fb and Twitter, the place the algorithm is particularly designed to maintain you scrolling via your feed (all the higher to strip-mine your private information and promote it to advertisers, my expensive!). Even worse, I have a tendency to make use of social media as an escape from dealing with the personal issues and points in my very own life. It’s time for me to cease discussing and snarking about different individuals’s issues, and focus alone!

I now contemplate it unlikely that I’ll use any corporate-run social media in future (besides in instances like YouTube, the place it’s successfully filtered through Feedbin to keep away from the advice algorithm). My expertise over the previous few years with social media has been an eye-opener, and it’ll inform my choices and actions going ahead. I used to avidly hunt down new social networks to hitch, relationship again to my time on Friendster twenty years in the past; now, I are likely to run within the different path!

I initially checked out Mastodon as a alternative app for Twitter, and I had put loads of my effort into constructing a social community there over the previous ten months. The neighborhood there may be nice; general, they’re a high-quality bunch of individuals. Nonetheless, I’ve additionally determined to take a psychological well being break from Mastodon, too. Regardless that it was a much better place than the poisonous dumpster hearth which Twitter has change into beneath Elon Musk, I’m critically beginning to query why I really feel the necessity to use any social media in any respect.

I nonetheless have and can proceed to run my weblog and my Discord server, however I do really feel it’s time for me to step again and do a whole and utter reset of how I exploit social media, going ahead. I’m most likely going to need to battle via some powerful Reddit withdrawal signs! However I do suppose that is the most effective step ahead for me.

Want me luck!

UPDATE Feb. fifteenth, 2023: Effectively, I can verify that I’m undoubtedly battling Reddit withdrawal! I did give in to temptation at lunch right this moment at work, and I poked my nostril again into Hollis Uncensored right this moment, and anyone had simply posted this well-written clarification, which I share in full:

There’s a rift within the snark neighborhood proper now, and it’s vital to clear issues up. All factors are up for dialogue, as a result of dialogue is the idea of our neighborhood. (If you happen to don’t need to learn all of it, the gist is within the first and final paragraphs)

It’s potential to be respectful of somebody’s grieving household and pals with out sugarcoating their actions. Like all people, Dave was greater than a one-dimensional character.

So right here goes:

  1. An individual’s demise doesn’t negate their dangerous conduct and the results of it. Dave had a large function within the poisonous positivity self-help world the place one in every of his dangerous acts was pushing susceptible individuals to pay for his recommendation somewhat than go to an expert (simply have a look at the issues he stated about his guide whereas berating his followers throughout pancake-gate). He bought this guru recommendation whereas in energetic habit and spiraling psychological well being. He bought a really dangerous lie, and habit was an integral a part of that. Habit and psychological well being considerations are unavoidable subjects of dialogue right here. He additionally knowingly bought a pair’s retreat for THOUSANDS of {dollars} to determined couple’s whereas understanding his personal marriage was on the rocks, and he had no enterprise giving out recommendation. There are such a lot of extra problematic issues, which is why this sub exists.
  2. His youngsters and household are victims in multiple method. Throughout his meltdown, he repeatedly denied his little one meals (who was too younger to make meals for herself) for HOURS, whereas he ignored her, snapped at her, and badmouthed her. He gave the impression to be beneath the affect but once more, which is a related and vital remark as a result of he was answerable for caring for susceptible youngsters on the time. That’s little one endangerment. That’s not extreme hypothesis; that’s a truth primarily based on the definition of the phrases. Past that, he was repeatedly and relentlessly condescending to Rachel and Heidi. Each time he confirmed his children on social media, he barely engaged with them and was hyperfocused on how he appeared. He used his children as content material. Personally, I imagine that got here out of a spot of deep discontent and poor self-image, however that doesn’t negate the impact it had on his household. We begged him to concentrate to his children and have interaction with them, and we hoped he would. We had been rooting for him when he received assist for his habit, and we had been nervous about his psychological and bodily well being as they appeared to say no currently. I imagine he genuinely cherished his children, however somebody can love their children and nonetheless do hurt.
  3. As I touched on above, the final consensus is that we don’t armchair-diagnose HOWEVER there’s a distinction between saying somebody is XYZ and saying we’re involved as a result of somebody is exhibiting traits of XYZ and is behaving in a dangerous method. A great instance of that is Heidi’s disordered consuming. It’s okay to say that (from what we’re capable of see) she is exercising excessively with out taking in sufficient energy, seems to be more and more unhealthy, and seems to be participating in textbook body-checking behaviors. That is an extremely vital remark as a result of she has susceptible individuals paying her for exercise and consuming plans. We’re additionally genuinely nervous about her well being, similar to we nervous about Dave. Nonetheless, as a lot as we fear about her well being, we’re extra nervous in regards to the hundreds of susceptible individuals she influences. It’s not price sparing the emotions of 1 individual as that price of so many others.
  4. We held Dave accountable for his actions but in addition hoped he would get respectable assist and get out of the scamming guru world he was so deeply in. I believe most of us nonetheless maintain that hope for Heidi, too, however she is victimizing others and we shouldn’t cease speaking about that. Personally, I don’t suppose it’s potential for Rachel as a result of she doesn’t exhibit the naivete of Heidi and Dave. A part of the absurdity of the Hollis/Powell crew is that they are going to rake you for hundreds of {dollars}, promoting you on their all-knowingness whereas having very primary “epiphanies” (a.okay.a. issues that the majority of us discovered between center college and faculty) proper in entrance of your eyes and so they don’t see how incongruous that’s.

Finally, there may be an overlap right here of conventional snark and real accountability and hope. That’s the purpose. Whereas there may be levity in joking about their antics, this isn’t only for enjoyable. There HAS to be levity, as a result of the implications of their actions are very darkish. That being stated, there may be at all times the underlying aim right here, which is to carry mild to their scamming and assist stop them from making the most of others. We hope that that features the perpetrators getting assist as a result of we do care about these individuals, however our precedence is in caring for his or her victims.

The important thing half is within the final paragraph. There’s certainly an overlap within the snarker communities between mean-girl, conventional snark, and the act of holding influencers like this accountable for his or her phrases and deeds. Do I really feel responsible that I participated within the snark about Dave? Sure, a bit of. However, on the identical time, we snarkers had been taking part in a job in educating ourselves about individuals who grift and rip-off, with a view to assist determine the behaviour in others, and to assist those that had been (and sometimes, nonetheless are) victimized by such “influencers.” It was additionally an training within the dynamics of parasocial relationships on social media, and at have a look at these individuals who select to dwell within the public eye, for higher or for worse.

UPDATE February twenty first, 2023: Public relations advisor Molly McPherson chats about Dave Hollis’ demise and its impression on the Hollis Uncensored subreddit with fellow podcaster Emily Rose, in the latest episode of Molly’s podcast, Indestructible PR with Molly McPherson. You’ll be able to take heed to the 44-minute podcast (which incorporates an enchanting common dialogue about parasocial relationships) on Apple or Spotify, or nevertheless you devour your podcast content material.

Indestructible PR Podcast
Molly McPherson’s podcast about Dave Hollis and the Hollis Uncensored neighborhood

Favored it? Then please contemplate supporting Ryan Schultz on Patreon! Whilst little as US$1 a month unlocks unique patron advantages. Thanks!

become a patron button